Last Friday, I passed my MA thesis defense! My thesis title is “Contradiction, Paradox, and Irony: Philosophical and Theological Stances of Hegel and Kierkegaard.” For Geoff and Myles who asked, there it is.
John Wright was my adviser, and my two readers were Dr. Rob Thompson and Chris Simpson (my ‘external’ reader at LCCS). The defense went rather well, and it was oddly a lot of fun. My committee asked some great critical questions, and they tell me I handled them well. Turns out they are passing the thesis “with distinction,” which I’m extremely humbled about, as apparently I didn’t think this was even an option.
I know many have already asked to read the thesis, but I may have forgotten a few names. If you’re still interested, please leave me a comment below and I’ll e-mail it your direction (just put your e-mail address in the e-mail box, no need to put it in the comment itself–I’ll see it). The thesis is around 110 pages double-spaced, ~41,000 words. I’d love to hear your thoughts, further questions and criticism.
The evening after the defense, we had a small, casual graduation reception. The purpose of this particular reception was to allow our parents to meet the professors in the department. I introduced my parents to all the professors and it was a really pleasant time, enjoying finger foods and the like. As time was getting short with my parents needing to help my sister Jenna move out of her dorm, we had just enough time to introduce my parents to one remaining prof, Dr. Rob Thompson — one of my thesis readers. With apologies to Dr. Rob Thompson, Hegel, Schelling, and most of all my parents, the conversation ended with something that very much sounded like this:
My Dad: I have to commute a total of 3 hours every work day. It really puts a strain on my back. Of course Janet here only –
My Mom (Janet): Yeah, I only have to commute about 6 miles to work!
Dr. Thompson: When I was in Nampa, Idaho [at NNU] I would get annoyed if it took me longer than 5 minutes to get to work.
Me: Wow, yeah, it takes me 25-30 minutes to get to work in the mornings.
Dr. Thompson: The delays were almost always caused by a cow in the road. There’s another cow in the road this time–it was always a cow.
Dad: That happens a lot where we live too, and it gets incredibly dangerous. Not too long ago a whole heard of Blank Angus got out and were on the road — and you couldn’t see them!
Me: Whoa! That’s like the “black ice” of cows!
Them: [laughter]
Me again: Even better, it’s like “the night in which all cows are black!!!”
Them: [crickets]
Graduation the day after the defense was really cool. Apparently, graduating makes people forget awful philosophy jokes. To tell you the truth, I didn’t really think much about graduation until I was actually there. I was so focused on just getting the thesis done, and then trying to not focus on much at all in the week and a half of relaxation before the defense, that I kind of forgot that graduation is a big deal. That, and the PLNU campus turns into a crazy zoo. They have split the graduation up in to one graduate graduation and two undergraduate graduations, so it smooths things over a bit regarding the zoo factor. I must admit that it was nice to feel young at graduation: most of the people were slightly older than me, if not twice my age who were graduating. Aside from a friend of mine who is 65 years old in the MA theology program (and he has the energy and heart of a 20-year-old!), most of the students in our program are about 3 years younger than me, at least.
After graduation, Tiana threw a graduation party for me at our good friend Ester’s house. It was a totally awesome time of relaxation and conversation with good friends and family. In addition to my parents and sister, Tiana’s mom, sister Shalina, brother Stephen, and sister-in-law Shannon where all there as well. I was really thankful for being surrounded with good, loving people.
Okay, now rewind a couple days to Thursday morning, the day before my thesis defense. It was already a roller coaster of a week. I wake up, check my e-mail and decide to check out this page (I’d been hitting the refresh button on it all week). My name is printed on that page on the bottom, which means… It’s official: I GOT THE OVERSEAS RESEARCH SCHOLARSHIP!!! This means that the funding for my PhD tuition is basically paid in full! (technically it’s for a year of funding but it ‘renews’ each year upon ‘satisfactory progress’ or something like that). I was pretty emotional and immediately called Tiana who was still on her way to work to let her know the good news. She was super happy and relieved — we were not planning on taking out more loans on top of the undergraduate loans that we are still paying off. And then I called John Wright, who was also incredibly stoked. So, the next day I went into my thesis defense with the semester-long weight of worrying about the ORS lifted off my shoulders.
Tiana and I decided to wait until our parents arrived in San Diego before telling them. Now that they know and are super excited for us, they are all incredibly eager to visit us in Robin Hood country. So now, what remains is trying to figure out all the details on how exactly we can get over there so that they have somebody to visit. We’ve already received some extremely helpful tips from a couple of students already in the program (thanks Anthony and Aaron!). And, Tiana also found this incredible resource which, although that guy attends Durham University, should still apply pretty well to the UK in general.
By September 22, I will begin my PhD studies in theology at the University of Nottingham to study under Conor Cunningham. We hope to move to Nottingham a month ahead of that time to find a place to live and do some job hunting for Tiana. There will not be any employment restrictions placed upon on her from my student visa–the only restrictions will be on me. I will most likely continue doing work for The Centre of Theology and Philosophy, and perhaps some assorted side projects for some extra scratch, but my full-time computer programmer days are coming to an end. There’s a bunch of other details of the move to work out, of course, but this post has gone on long enough, and I’m sure we’ll figure those things out in due time.
Thanks to everybody for all the encouragement and conversations along the way. Special thanks to my wife Tiana for her encouragement, laughter, for reminding me what is really important, and most of all her love. She’s a keeper.
I honestly have no idea how we ended up in this position to be able to move to Nottingham for PhD work, but we are really very thankful for everything.
[Cross-posted to tianaanderic.com]
Congrats, Eric!
Hey Eric, First of all, a hearty congratulations on graduation, the thesis defense, and the funding for more graduate school.
I found your site doing trying to track down a book called “Tayloring Reformed Epistemology.”
I’m currently a Ph.D. in philosophy at Fordham University. It seems we have many similar interests. (I’m a Hegel/Kierkegaard fan, and interested in the intersection of philosophy and theology.)
Anyway, would love to take a look at your thesis, so I thought I’d ask for a copy.
Many, many congratulations Eric on both graduating (esp. with a thesis with distinction) and on the ORS! It is funny and frightening to think how the decision of some people sitting in a room in the south of England can save you tens and tens of thousands of dollars. Anyways, great job on getting the ORS, particularly as they are getting harder and harder to get (as ‘those in the know’ tell me). Please do send along the thesis if you have a chance. Congratulations again.
Yeah, sorry Eric, I forgot to follow up…please send me your thesis indeed. Congratulations. Peace.
j.david.belcher@gmail.com
Congratulations. Nottingham has a great reputation here in the UK for theology.
Eric, there is a ton here to congratulate you on, so, congrats for it all! I’m sure this is a pretty exciting time.
Also, I would love to read your thesis. I’ve been reading Kierkegaard myself lately and feel that my understanding(s) are limited because of my unfamiliarity with Hegel beyond secondary sources. Not sure if your thesis would help here or further confuse, giving me some more questions to follow through on, but either way it would be enjoyable!
Grace and Peace.
Thanks y’all! I’ve sent out my thesis to those who have asked. Now it’s time for me to begin a relaxing weekend.
That’s great news! I’d still love to read the thesis: myles.werntz@gmail.com
Hey Eric,
Congrats again on your graduation and thesis. Also, congrats and good luck on your move for PhD work! By the way, I would like to read your thesis if you would send it to me: singertenor{at}gmail.com
Nottingham: fantastic!
This is great news Eric! I’m so happy to hear this. How long of a time do you expect/anticipate for being in Nottingham? And please send me the thesis , too.
Congratulations on finishing and on the funding for your PhD! What a terrific opportunity!
Dale, the program is a 3-year fulltime research PhD.
Thanks again, y’all!
Eric,
Congratulations on everything – things seem to have worked out quite well. Good work brother. If you don’t mind sending the thesis along to one more person…please do. Thanks!
Eric,
As I have 120+ books, along with articles, to read this summer, please DO NOT send me your thesis at present. ;)
Huge congratulations on finishing, defending well, and getting such distinction! I’m glad it was a time of encouragement for you.
If your program in the UK is 3 years, we’ll probably finish up our Ph.D.s at the same time, although I’m 2 years into mine here. Funny that! I know that funding is exceptionally necessary. Congratulations again! What a great time.
looks like I am late to this party. Congratulations Eric! sling me that thesis when you get a chance!
Dear Eric,
I would love to read a copy of your thesis, and best of luck in Nottingham!
Cheers,
Araglin
Hey! We didn’t know you guys were coming to Europe! When will you arrive in England? We are going to be in Manchester and London in September. Maybe we could hook up. Suggestion: bring lots of money–the GBP and the low $$$ are killing us!!! Maybe now we can get Shalina to come over here! You will have to visit Budapest, you know!
Eric, Congratulations to you on your thesis as well as scholarship for doctoral work! I wish many blessings to you and your bride as you traverse the pond to England. I would love to read your thesis. Life after Loma here in Reno has been terrific, and we are really digging the whole family-house-yard thing. Rich is coming out to see us in another couple of weeks and we are stoked. Take care and I look forward to some enlightening reading.